Grant of pre-trial injunction against article publication may have severe ramifications on freedom of speech: SC – World News Network

Date:

Share post:

New Delhi [India], March 27 (ANI): The Supreme Court has recently said that the grant of a pre-trial injunction by courts against the publication of an article may have severe ramifications on the right to freedom of speech of the author and the public’s right to know.
A bench of Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud and Justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra noted that the grant of an interim injunction before the trial commences often acts as a ‘death sentence’ to the material sought to be published, well before the allegations have been proven.
It emphasised that courts must be cautious in passing injunction orders to restrain the publication of media articles, particularly when it is yet to be proved whether the content of such articles is malicious or false.
“While granting ad-interim injunctions in defamation suits, the potential of using prolonged litigation to prevent free speech and public participation must also be kept in mind by courts,” the bench said in its recent order.
It has set aside a trial court’s order directing international media group Bloomberg to take down an allegedly defamatory news article against Zee Entertainment.
The order of the apex court came on a plea filed by Bloomberg against the March 14 order of the Delhi High Court, which dismissed its appeal against the trial court order.
“An injunction, particularly ex-parte, should not be granted without establishing that the content sought to be restricted is ‘malicious’ or ‘palpably false’. Granting interim injunctions before the trial commences in a cavalier manner results in the stifling of public debate. In other words, courts should not grant ex-parte injunctions except in exceptional cases where the defence advanced by the respondent would undoubtedly fail at trial. In all other cases, injunctions against the publication of material should be granted only after a full-fledged trial is conducted or, in exceptional cases, after the respondent is given a chance to make their submissions,” the apex court stated in its order.
The bench stressed that in suits concerning defamation by media platforms and/or journalists, an additional consideration is “balancing the fundamental right to free speech with the
right to reputation and privacy” must be borne in mind.
“The constitutional mandate of protecting journalistic expression cannot be understated, and courts must tread cautiously while granting pre-trial interim injunctions,” it added.
Bloomberg had approached the apex court, and the single-judge bench of the High Court had said there was no ground to interfere with the ex-parte interim order passed by the Additional District Judge (ADJ) on the lawsuit by Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited (ZEEL) over the article published on February 21 and ordered Bloomberg to comply with the direction in three days.
On March 1, the ADJ directed Bloomberg to take down the allegedly defamatory article within a week while saying Zee had established a “prima facie case for passing ad-interim ex-parte orders of injunction.”
The court had said the balance of convenience was in Zee’s favour and irreparable loss and injury might be caused to the company if the injunction was not granted.
The court made the observations in a case concerning an article published by Bloomberg that alleged that a $241 million accounting irregularity had been found in the books of ZEEL by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
After the article was published on February 21, Zee filed a defamation suit before a Delhi district court against Bloomberg and its journalists, Anto Antony, Saikat Das and Preeti Singh. (ANI)


Disclaimer: This story is auto-generated from a syndicated feed of ANI; only the image & headline may have been reworked by News Services Division of World News Network Inc Ltd and Palghar News and Pune News and World News


Paris Appreciation Awards

Read More

World Polls

Read More

Short News

Read More

Indian Bureaucrats

Read More

World Talent Management

Read More

World Brand Ambassadors

Read More

Film Critics

Read More

Influencers

Read More

Video Press Release

Read More

podcasts Press Release

Read More

Social Media

Read More

Colleges Press Release

Read More

Business Press Release

Read More

Critics Press Release

Read More

Fashion Marketing Press Releases

Read More

Gaming Press Release

Read More

Finance Press Release Distribution

Read More

Creative Press Release

Read More

Animals Press Release

Read More

Tech News Press Release

Read More

Cryptomarket Press Release

Read More

Fitness News Press Release

Read More

Gadgets Press Release

Read More

Gardening Press Release

Read More

Stockmarket Press Release

Read More

Product Reviewers and Marketing

Read More

Crypto Press Release Distribution

Read More

Film Festivals Marketing

Read More

India Real Estate Marketing

Read More

Indian Medical Tourism

Read More

Travel Marketing Press Release

Read More

Health Marketing Press Release

Read More

Events Marketing Press Release

Read More

Restaurants Marketing Press Release

Read More

City Business Listing

Read More

World Import Export

Read More

PR Franchise

Read More

Radio Press Release Distribution

Read More

Movies Distribution

Read More

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

spot_img

Related articles

India’s travel and tourism sector poised for growth: Projected revenue to reach USD 23.72 bn by 2024 – World News Network

As per Invest India, India announced 100 per cent Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in tourism-related ventures, including the development of hotels, resorts, and recreational facilities, in a move aimed at fostering growth and development in the tourism sector as of 2023.

Aranthangi’s Elshaddai School Students Achieve Record-breaking Feats and Set Elite World Records – World News Network

Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], April 15: Elshaddai Group of Institutions, Aranthangi, proudly presents the Elshaddai World Records Festival 2024, celebrating 4th year of academic excellence. Students showcased exceptional skills, recognized by prestigious record-keeping organizations which includes Elite World Records, Asian Records Academy, India Records Academy, and Tamilan Book of Record, providing inspiration for aspiring achievers. These achievements underscore the school's commitment to nurturing talent and fostering a culture of innovation and excellence.

India’s passenger EV market will hot up in next 3-4 years – World News Network

This EV surge in EV sales can be can be attributed to factors like, government incentive schemes like PLIs, infrastructure development like more EV charging points, increasing urban consumer interest, and government push to meet green target.

Election months typically see less capex utilisation: Bank of Baroda report – World News Network

A capital expenditure, or capex, is used to set up long-term physical or fixed assets.

Paris Appreciation Awards

Read More

World Polls

Read More

Short News

Read More

Indian Bureaucrats

Read More

World Talent Management

Read More

World Brand Ambassadors

Read More

Film Critics

Read More

Influencers

Read More

Video Press Release

Read More

podcasts Press Release

Read More

Social Media

Read More

Colleges Press Release

Read More

Business Press Release

Read More

Critics Press Release

Read More

Fashion Marketing Press Releases

Read More

Gaming Press Release

Read More

Finance Press Release Distribution

Read More

Creative Press Release

Read More

Animals Press Release

Read More

Tech News Press Release

Read More

Cryptomarket Press Release

Read More

Fitness News Press Release

Read More

Gadgets Press Release

Read More

Gardening Press Release

Read More

Stockmarket Press Release

Read More

Product Reviewers and Marketing

Read More

Crypto Press Release Distribution

Read More

Film Festivals Marketing

Read More

India Real Estate Marketing

Read More

Indian Medical Tourism

Read More

Travel Marketing Press Release

Read More

Health Marketing Press Release

Read More

Events Marketing Press Release

Read More

Restaurants Marketing Press Release

Read More

City Business Listing

Read More

World Import Export

Read More

PR Franchise

Read More

Radio Press Release Distribution

Read More

Movies Distribution

Read More